Every thesis and every call is scored against the market from the day it was made, with the price of that day. Nothing is backfilled, and misses stay on the record.
Measures Whether a thesis or a call did better than the market over the same days
Who makes it Code, from daily closing prices. No AI decides whether something was right.
Updated After every trading day’s close Your theses How a thesis is scored
Day 0
You open it. Entry is that day’s close.
Day 5
First verdict: ahead or behind the S&P 500
You close it
Played out if it beat the S&P 500, else missed
Day 0
You open it. Entry is that day’s close.
Day 5
First verdict: ahead or behind the S&P 500
You close it
Played out if it beat the S&P 500, else missed
Just opened
On track / behind
Benchmark The S&P 500 (SPY), over exactly the same days
Entry and exit The close on the day you open the thesis and the close on the day you close it, or today while open
First verdict After 5 trading closes. A day’s move is noise.
Outcome Open: on track or behind. Closed: played out or missed. A tie counts as behind.
Left out Watchlist ideas, which are not positions, and theses with no price for their dates (counted and shown)
Voices you follow Parra reads posts that say a company will rise or fall. A call counts once: repeating the same view is not a new call; only a change of mind is.
Entry The close on the day of the post
Read at 30, 90, 180 and 365 days
A hit The stock beat the S&P 500 for a rising call, or trailed it for a falling one
Trust Hits at 90 days, pulled toward 50% while there are few calls: (hits + 1) ÷ (calls + 2). One lucky call can’t make a voice look perfect.
Parra’s own analyses Parra keeps the same score on itself. Each analysis is read against the company’s sector fund, and its stories are checked once a year has passed.
Read at 3, 6 and 12 months, against the sector ETF
A hit A buy rating when the stock beat its sector ETF, a sell rating when it trailed it, a hold when it stayed within 10% of it
Stories After a year: which story the company landed nearest, whether it stayed between bear and bull, and a Brier score for the likelihoods
Calibration Stories given about 30% should land about 30% of the time. The record shows how often they did.
Worked example: a thesis on Northwind Semis Opened on 3 March at a close of $80. The S&P 500 closed at 500 that day.
Closed on 1 September at $92 (+15%). The S&P 500 was at 540 (+8%). The thesis played out, 7 points ahead.
A made-up company, to show the method. Not a view on any stock.
What it can’t tell you
Beating the S&P 500 over a few months can be luck. Look at how many theses or calls a record holds. Dividends are not counted yet, for the stock or the benchmark. A record looks back. It doesn’t say the next call will be right. Evidence, not advice. These are readings of company filings and market prices. They don’t say what to buy or sell, and they don’t know your situation.
Value range and price bet →
Three stories about the business, each valued the same way, and the growth today’s price needs.